I just wanted to point this out in case it's an issue that other people have had, but when starting a server, the console said that it properly started, but when connecting, it connected to someone else's server. Restarting seems to have fixed the issue, but I just want to point out this issue so that people know what to do if they try to join their server and it puts them into the wrong server. I hope that this is not a recurring issue and hope to bring it up with the Aternos mods.
The Aternos forums are now deprecated
Learn more about this change here.
For help regarding Aternos, we recommend you to visit our support center.