Plugin denied

The Aternos forums are now deprecated

Learn more about this change here.

For help regarding Aternos, we recommend you to visit our support center.

1st Official Post

    Hi, if I may add, Roman, (I am in no way, shape, or form affiliated with the person who made the request) but I'd like to urge you to reconsider, I was actually wanting to place a request for the same plugin aswell, as the plugin is, just as described:"loads of fun". I also think that only because the plugin is new and/or doesn't have any ratings, updates or comments, shouldn't determine whether or not the plugin is good for use. As with this method of determining a plugin's usefulness, newer plugin creators don't have a chance in getting their plugins on here.
    Again, please do reconsider, it's seriously an awesome plugin and deserves a place in an awesome server creation network.
    Kind regards, Vinni

    Quote from Vinni

    Hi, if I may add, Roman, (I am in no way, shape, or form affiliated with the person who made the request) but I'd like to urge you to reconsider, I was actually wanting to place a request for the same plugin aswell, as the plugin is, just as described:"loads of fun". I also think that only because the plugin is new and/or doesn't have any ratings, updates or comments, shouldn't determine whether or not the plugin is good for use. As with this method of determining a plugin's usefulness, newer plugin creators don't have a chance in getting their plugins on here.
    Again, please do reconsider, it's seriously an awesome plugin and deserves a place in an awesome server creation network.
    Kind regards, Vinni

    this is a requirement. I am pretty sure that no exceptions will be made as without a real good reason. And without ratings, updates, comments etc. They can't judge as in, how safe, necessary and good this plugin is.

    Quote from Joshy | #galaxymax

    this is a requirement. I am pretty sure that no exceptions will be made as without a real good reason. And without ratings, updates, comments etc. They can't judge as in, how safe, necessary and good this plugin is.

    Hi,

    I could see why, but let's talk hypothetically.

    Hypothetically, what's stopping me from paying for bots that someone made and use them to make comments, ratings?

    With that said, the system of checking plugins by looking at comments, ratings is severely flawed, and is bypassable by someone who really wants their plugin on Aternos.

    Furthermore, if I were to do that, and make it look realistic by not doing all the comments and ratings within a small time frame, I'm guessing the plugin would be accepted. As for the updates? That's just dumb, updates shouldn't mean anything. If a plugin is good and finished, why should it require updates. To be fair, the creator of the plugin could just pretend to make an update and actually do nothing, and nobody would know.

    Kind regards,

    Vinni

    sorry, but i don't get what updates have to do with this?

    And then besides that, i'm guessing the mods get tested. Which they would only be, if the downloads, ratings, comments and such are sufficient. ( this i am all guessing on )

    Quote from Joshy | #galaxymax

    sorry, but i don't get what updates have to do with this?

    And then besides that, i'm guessing the mods get tested. Which they would only be, if the downloads, ratings, comments and such are sufficient. ( this i am all guessing on )

    Hey,

    Well, you mentioned the updates in your first comment, so I was commenting on that.

    As for the testing part? Doesn't really make a difference, does it?

    If I put ratings and comments on a plugin that's even half-good and fun, it'd probably get added.

    As for the downloads, I didn't see Roman mentioning downloads so I'm not including that.

    Kind regards,

    Vinni

    Sorry I forgot about the updates part.

    However, the testing part does matter. If a mod/plugin/modpack doesn't suffice, then it probably won't be added. And downloads do matter, according to the requirements listed in the thread pinned in plugin/mod/modpack requests.

    And you can use bots, sure. But I'm pretty sure that if a ton of downloads, ratings and comments get added in only a short amount of time, that it'll be quite noticable

    Quote from Joshy | #galaxymax

    Sorry I forgot about the updates part.

    However, the testing part does matter. If a mod/plugin/modpack doesn't suffice, then it probably won't be added. And downloads do matter, according to the requirements listed in the thread pinned in plugin/mod/modpack requests.

    And you can use bots, sure. But I'm pretty sure that if a ton of downloads, ratings and comments get added in only a short amount of time, that it'll be quite noticable

    Hi,

    Well, I did mention that the comments, ratings and downloads wouldn't be added in a short time frame, so it shouldn't be noticeable.

    Again, testing is easy to pass if your plugin is half good.

    Kind regards,

    Vinni

    Quote from Delected

    Also, it's not on Bukkit or Spigot CURRENTLY. Maybe once it is on Spigot, Bukkit, or even Songoda and it gets more popular, it may be accepted.

    Its on spigot. Which still doesn't change that it won't be added at this moment

  • Roman

    Closed the thread.